Fan Jian didn't give a clear answer to Liu Ruyu's feelings. Some documents mentioned that Fan Jian's feelings for Liu Ruyu were rated at 50 points. They believed that he paid more attention to Fan Xian and ignored Liu Ruyu. However, other documents mentioned that Liu Ruyu loved Fan Jian deeply and was willing to be his concubine. Although Fan Jian did not support Liu Ruyu, their relationship gradually reconciled and became as close as a mother and son. Thus, there was no clear answer to the question of whether Fan Jian loved Liu Ruyu or not.
Liu Ruyu was Fan Jian's concubine and also Fan Xian's aunt. At first, Liu Ruyu was not friendly to Fan Xian. She was worried that he would fight for the family property and was hostile to him. However, as the plot developed, Liu Ruyu's attitude gradually changed. In the end, she reconciled with Fan Xian and became as close as mother and son. She did not care about Fan Jian's status as a concubine. She chose to marry him out of true love and feelings for him. Liu Ruyu's character displayed an independent, intelligent, and determined personality. She accompanied Fan Xian and witnessed his growth and transformation. In the end, Liu Ruyu was made the official wife by Fan Jian. Her ending was perfect.
Liu Ruyu's attitude toward Fan Xian had initially been to make things difficult for him. She was worried that Fan Xian would fight for the family property. However, after Fan Xian helped Fan Sizhe out of his predicament many times, Liu Ruyu's attitude changed. She began to treat Fan Xian differently. This might be because she realized that Fan Xian did not pose a threat to her and her son. Liu Ruyu had originally been hostile toward Fan Xian, but this hostility was understandable. She was Fan Xian's second concubine. She was worried that Fan Xian would turn the tables and fight for the family property. Thus, Liu Ruyu's change in attitude toward Fan Xian was understandable.
In " Celebrating Years," the relationship between Fan Xian and Liu Ruyu was tense at the beginning. Liu Ruyu was worried that Fan Xian would fight for the family property, so she was hostile to him. However, as the plot progressed, Liu Ruyu's attitude changed. She began to treat Fan Xian differently. The specific plot and development were not mentioned in the search results provided.
In " Celebrating Years," the relationship between Fan Xian and Liu Ruyu was tense at the beginning. Liu Ruyu was worried that Fan Xian would fight for the family property, so she was hostile to him. However, as the plot progressed, Liu Ruyu's attitude changed. She began to treat Fan Xian differently. The specific reason was probably because she realized that Fan Xian did not pose a threat to her and her son. Fan Xian had helped Fan Sizhe out of his predicament many times in the play, which might have changed Liu Ruyu's view of him. Thus, Liu Ruyu's attitude changed from making things difficult for Fan Xian to treating him differently.
In " Celebrating Years," the relationship between Fan Xian and Liu Ruyu was rather tense at the beginning. Liu Ruyu was worried that Fan Xian would fight for the family property, so she made things difficult for him. However, as Fan Xian helped Fan Sizhe out of his predicament many times, Liu Ruyu's attitude changed. She began to treat Fan Xian differently, perhaps because she realized that Fan Xian was not as bad as she had imagined. Liu Ruyu's change in attitude toward Fan Xian showed her kindness and tolerance.
In " Celebrating Years," the relationship between Fan Xian and Liu Ruyu was tense at the beginning. Liu Ruyu was worried that Fan Xian would fight for the family property, so she was hostile to him. However, as the plot progressed, Liu Ruyu's attitude changed. She began to treat Fan Xian differently, and the relationship between the two gradually eased. The details were not mentioned.
In " Celebrating Years," the relationship between Fan Xian and Liu Ruyu was tense at the beginning. Liu Ruyu was worried that Fan Xian would fight for the family property, so she was hostile to him. However, as the plot progressed, Liu Ruyu's attitude changed. She began to treat Fan Xian differently. Perhaps it was because Fan Xian had helped Fan Sizhe out of his predicament many times, which made Liu Ruyu realize his value. The details of Fan Xian's flirtatious behavior with Liu Ruyu were not mentioned.
In " Celebrating Years," the relationship between Fan Xian and Liu Ruyu was rather tense at the beginning. Liu Ruyu was worried that Fan Xian would fight for the family property, so she made things difficult for him. However, as Fan Xian helped Fan Sizhe out of his predicament many times, Liu Ruyu's attitude changed. She began to treat Fan Xian differently, and the relationship between the two gradually eased. The specific plot and development were not mentioned in the search results provided.
In " Celebrating Years," the relationship between Fan Xian and Liu Ruyu was rather tense at the beginning. Liu Ruyu was worried that Fan Xian would fight for the family property, so she made things difficult for him. However, as Fan Xian helped Fan Sizhe out of his predicament many times, Liu Ruyu's attitude changed. She began to treat Fan Xian differently, and the relationship between the two gradually eased. The details of Fan Xian and Liu Ruyu's exchange of glances were not mentioned.
In " Celebrating Years," Fan Xian and Liu Ruyu's initial relationship was that of a concubine and a concubine. At first, Liu Ruyu was hostile toward Fan Xian, worried that he would fight for the family property. However, as the plot developed and Fan Xian helped Fan Sizhe out of his predicament many times, Liu Ruyu's attitude changed. She began to treat Fan Xian differently, perhaps because she realized that Fan Xian had no intention of attacking the mother and son. As a result, Liu Ruyu's attitude toward Fan Xian took a 180-degree turn.