Did Liu Ruyu treat Fan Xian well in the past few years?

Liu Ruyu, who had been in the middle of the Qing years, was not friendly to Fan Xian at first. She was worried that he would fight for the family property and was hostile to him. However, as the plot developed, Liu Ruyu's attitude gradually changed. In the end, she reconciled with Fan Xian and became as close as mother and son. Thus, it could be said that Liu Ruyu treated Fan Xian well.

Liu Ruyu, who had been in the middle of the Qing years, was not friendly to Fan Xian at first. She was worried that he would fight for the family property. However, as the plot developed, Liu Ruyu's attitude gradually changed. In the end, she reconciled with Fan Xian and became as close as mother and son. Liu Ruyu displayed her intelligence, kindness, and endurance. Therefore, it was impossible to simply define Liu Ruyu as a good person or a bad person.

In " Celebrating Years," Liu Ruyu was not friendly to Fan Xian at first. She was worried that he would fight for the family property and was hostile to him. However, as the plot developed, Liu Ruyu's attitude gradually changed. In the end, she reconciled with Fan Xian and became as close as mother and son. Thus, it could be said that Liu Ruyu treated Fan Xian well.

In " Celebrating Years," Liu Ruyu did not explicitly mention the time when she was nice to Fan Xian. However, it could be seen that Liu Ruyu's attitude toward Fan Xian had gradually changed. At first, Liu Ruyu had been hostile to Fan Xian. She was worried that he would fight for the family property, so she had been hostile to him. However, as the plot developed, Liu Ruyu began to understand Fan Xian's character and saw how he defended his son in front of Fan Jian. Fan Xian had also helped Fan Sizhe out of his predicament many times, displaying his intelligence. These factors caused Liu Ruyu's view of Fan Xian to change. The relationship between the two gradually eased, and in the end, they became as close as mother and son. Thus, it could be said that Liu Ruyu treated Fan Xian well.

In " Celebrating Years," Liu Ruyu had initially been hostile toward Fan Xian, worried that he would fight for the family property. However, as the plot developed, Liu Ruyu gradually understood Fan Xian's character and saw his actions of protecting his son in front of Fan Jian. The relationship between the two gradually reconciled. As for when Liu Ruyu was good to Fan Xian, the search results provided did not specify a specific time. Therefore, he could not answer this question accurately.

Liu Ruyu's attitude toward Fan Xian was initially hostile. She was worried that he would fight for the family property and was hostile toward him. However, as the plot developed, Liu Ruyu gradually understood Fan Xian's character. Seeing him defend her son in front of Fan Jian, she began to take the initiative to reconcile with Fan Xian and eventually became as close as mother and son. The specific plot and development were not mentioned in the search results provided.

At first, Liu Ruyu had a negative attitude toward Fan Xian and had harmed him many times, worried that he would fight for the family property. However, as the plot developed, Liu Ruyu began to like Fan Xian and became his most competent mother. She had never thought that Fan Xian's mistake was his fault. Instead, she had always helped him get away with it. Liu Ruyu treated Fan Xian as her own. Not only did she teach him the rules of the Palace, but she also helped him fend off foreign enemies. The exact time was not mentioned in the search results provided.

Liu Ruyu's attitude toward Fan Xian changed as the plot developed. At first, Liu Ruyu was hostile toward Fan Xian, worried that he would fight for the family property. However, as the plot developed, Liu Ruyu gradually understood Fan Xian's character and saw his actions of protecting his son in front of Fan Jian. Liu Ruyu realized that Fan Xian had no hostility toward her and her son. Even when Fan Sizhe was wrongly accused by his father, Fan Xian had stood up to defend him. This made Liu Ruyu change her view of Fan Xian. In addition, Liu Ruyu understood Fan Xian's true identity and knew that he was a Prince. Thus, there was no possibility of him fighting over the family property, so she let down her guard against him. Even though Liu Ruyu had her own selfish motives and hoped to obtain some benefits from Fan Xian, she still helped Fan Xian a lot and became his role model. All in all, Liu Ruyu was good to Fan Xian because she had discovered his strengths and had the mentality to change and reconcile.

In " Celebrating Years," Lady Liu had initially been hostile to Fan Xian, worried that he would steal his son Fan Sizhe's position. However, as Fan Xian's power increased, Lady Liu's attitude gradually changed. She began to wholeheartedly support Fan Xian. She helped Fan Xian pull strings in the harem and protect him from harm. She also supported Fan Xian's decision when Fan Sizhe was involved in the Baoyue Brothel case. In the end, Fan Jian resigned from all his official positions and took Lady Liu to Ten Family Village to manage the new palace treasury and provide financial support for Fan Xian. Concubine Liu abandoned the circle of nobility in Jingdou and chose to live in seclusion with her husband, living a happy life. In short, Lady Liu's protection of Fan Xian in " Celebrating Years " was out of recognition and affection for him. Thus, it could be said that Lady Liu treated Fan Xian well.

Lady Liu was good to Fan Xian. Although Lady Liu had initially held a hostile attitude toward Fan Xian, worried that he would steal her son Fan Sizhe's position, as the plot developed, Lady Liu's attitude gradually changed. She began to wholeheartedly support Fan Xian. She helped Fan Xian pull strings in the harem and protect him from harm. Fan Xian's marriage was an important moment, and Lady Liu was as busy with the wedding arrangements as she was with her own son. In addition, Lady Liu also discovered that Fan Xian was a very good person. He treated Fan Sizhe well and had managed to mediate the relationship between father and son in the family. Thus, from the information provided, Lady Liu treated Fan Xian well.