Why were there so many historians smearing the Ming Dynasty, such as Jin Yong and Yi Zhongtian?

Mr. Yi Zhongtian's taste is better than Jin Yong's.

Yi Zhongtian was a famous historian and emcee. He had commented on ancient Chinese history in his works. These evaluations often involved the politics, economy, culture, and other aspects of different dynasties. Yi Zhongtian had once put forward some views on the comparison between the Ming Dynasty and the Qing Dynasty, including: 1. The Ming Dynasty and the Qing Dynasty had different political systems. The Qing Dynasty adopted the autocratic and feudal monarchical system, while the Ming Dynasty was more open and implemented democratic politics. In terms of economy, the Qing Dynasty was relatively developed, especially in agriculture and craftsmanship. The Ming Dynasty, on the other hand, had some economic problems such as financial constraints and trade restrictions. In terms of culture, the traditional culture of the Qing Dynasty was more conservative, while the Ming Dynasty was more open. Some cultural innovation and literary schools appeared. Yi Zhongtian's view was not absolute, and it was also criticized by some historians and historians. There was no simple answer to the question of whether the Ming and Qing Dynasties were worse than the Qing Dynasty. Every dynasty had its own unique historical background and characteristics, and many factors needed to be considered when evaluating the same period of history.

Jin Yong is a famous Chinese martial arts novel. His works have influenced several generations of Chinese people. His novels were famous for their unique narrative style, rich character creation and profound thoughts. Jin Yong's novels were full of twists and turns, many characters, and complicated relationships. They were full of martial arts elements and myths and legends. There were many unforgettable scenes and characters in his novels, such as the love between Linghu Chong and Ren Yingying, the loyalty between Guo Jing and Huang Rong, etc. These plots and characters were deeply imprinted in people's hearts. Jin Yong's works were widely welcomed not only in China, but also in Asia and around the world. His novels have been translated into many languages and adapted into movies, television dramas, stage plays and other forms of works that have influenced generations of readers and audiences. Therefore, Jin Yong, as the representative of Chinese martial arts novels, his works had become an important part of Chinese culture and attracted the attention and love of readers all over the world.

Mr. Yi Zhongtian believed that the Ming Dynasty was the darkest, most corrupt, and most brutal dynasty in Chinese history, mainly because there were many problems in the political, economic, and cultural aspects of the Ming Dynasty, which led to social unrest and the sufferings of the people. In the Ming Dynasty, the feudal monarchical system was still very popular. The power was highly concentrated, and the bureaucrats were corrupt. The social class was divided, making social governance very difficult. In terms of economy, the economic development of China during the Ming Dynasty encountered obstacles mainly due to the economic decline caused by wars and natural disasters. In addition, the Ming Dynasty also had many problems in the field of culture, such as literary inquisition, burning books and burying Confucianism. These incidents seriously restricted the development of thought and culture. The rulers of the Ming Dynasty also displayed extremely brutal behavior when dealing with problems. For example, Zhu Qiyu of the Ming Yingzong had imprisoned Zhu Qizhen of the Ming Yingzong in Nangong and ordered all the concubines and children of the Ming Yingzong to be killed. In addition, some rulers of the Ming Dynasty carried out large-scale suppression and slaughter of other people, such as Zhu Di and the Jingnan Army in the Battle of Jingnan. Therefore, the Ming Dynasty had many problems in politics, economy, culture and other aspects. Its rulers also showed extremely brutal behavior when dealing with problems. These factors made the Ming Dynasty considered to be the darkest, most corrupt and most brutal dynasty in Chinese history.

Yi Zhongtian was a famous historian and cultural critic. His comments and views on ancient Chinese history had been widely spread in online novels. However, Yi Zhongtian did not give a specific evaluation of whether the Ming Dynasty was the darkest or not, nor did he deny the view that the Qing Dynasty was better than the Ming Dynasty. The Ming Dynasty was a complicated dynasty in Chinese history. It experienced political, economic, cultural, social and other changes and challenges. In the Ming Dynasty, there were a series of political problems, such as bureaucrat corruption, local separation, excessive military power, etc., which led to the chaos and low efficiency of national governance. In terms of economy, the Ming Dynasty was also faced with internal and external troubles such as wars, disasters, trade friction, etc., which led to social instability and the loss of wealth. In terms of culture, there were many great ideologists and writers in the Ming Dynasty, such as Wang Yangming, Huang Zongxi, Gu Yanwu, Xin Qiji, etc. However, their thoughts and literature were also affected by the social and historical environment and could not get rid of the shackles of traditional thinking. In contrast, the Qing Dynasty was a relatively stable and unified dynasty in Chinese history. It had made great progress and development in politics, economy, culture and other aspects. The Qing Dynasty had achieved a more stable political system and social order. In terms of economy, the Qing Dynasty developed trade and agriculture, which promoted the development and prosperity of the country's economy. In terms of culture, there were many great ideologists and writers in the Qing Dynasty, such as Cao Xueqin, Nalan Xingde, Lao She, etc. Their thoughts and literature were deeply influenced and respected by later generations. Therefore, whether the Ming Dynasty was the darkest dynasty or whether the Qing Dynasty was better than the Ming Dynasty was a complicated problem that needed to be analyzed and evaluated from many aspects.

Many Ming Dynasty novelists were vague because the creation of novels during the Ming Dynasty was not as developed as it was now, and the definition and classification of novels at that time were not very clear. In addition, the author of the Ming Dynasty novel was vague because novels were a more private literary form at that time, and it was influenced by social and personal backgrounds. Therefore, the authors of Ming Dynasty novels might retain some vague expressions when writing to avoid affecting the legibility and artistic value of the novel.

The reason why Jin Yong's novels could be popular for so many years was because they had many unique characteristics, which made them a popular literary classic on a global scale. The plot of Jin Yong's novel is fascinating, full of thrilling and exciting plots and characters. The readers can deeply feel the plot and emotion in the novel. The characters in Jin Yong's novels are full of characters. Each character has its own unique personality and destiny. They all have profound thoughts and feelings that readers can resonate with. The language of Jin Yong's novels was concise, clear, and fluent, allowing readers to immerse themselves in the world of the novel in a short period of time. Jin Yong's novels have a very high reputation and influence. His stories and characters have become an important part of Chinese culture. They have been translated into many languages and spread widely around the world. With all these characteristics, Jin Yong's novel became a literary classic with global influence, attracting the attention and love of countless readers for many years.

Ming Fenghua was a Chinese ancient fantasy novel about the Ming Dynasty. In the novel, many people wore dragon robes because during the Ming Dynasty, dragon robes were a symbol of social status. Only the emperor and some nobles could wear them. The production of the dragon robe was very exquisite. It required the selection of the best fabric and craftsmanship. In addition, the dye and color of the dragon robe also needed to be very fine to ensure that its color and texture matched the image of the dragon. Therefore, only those nobles who had the ability and conditions to make dragon robes could wear it and enjoy a higher status in society. In the novel, wearing a dragon robe also represented the status and authority of the emperor. It was a form of respect and reverence for the emperor. Therefore, many people wore dragon robes in the novel to express their love and respect for the Ming emperor and Chinese history.

In Jin Yong's novels, many experts were disabled mainly because many experts would experience various life and death tests in the martial world. Sometimes, they would be seriously injured or even amputated by the enemy, resulting in some parts of their bodies being damaged. In addition, many of the masters in Jin Yong's novels had a special skill or talent. They could continuously improve their bodies and skills through continuous training and practice. Even if they experienced some defects, they could recover or surpass their original strength through various methods. Many of the masters in Jin Yong's novels were disabled, but there were also many masters who overcame their physical limitations and reached a higher realm through continuous hard work and training.

The main reasons why Jin Yong's novels belittled the Ming Dynasty and Chongzhen were as follows: In Jin Yong's novels, the Ming Dynasty was described as a corrupt and incompetent dynasty with internal and external troubles. At the end of the Ming Dynasty, political corruption, military slackness, and frequent natural disasters caused the country's finances to be extremely difficult. The army was unable to resist the invasion of foreign enemies, and various political struggles and divisions appeared within the army. The Ming emperors in Jin Yong's novels were often portrayed as stupid, incompetent, greedy, or cowardly. Emperor Chongzhen was portrayed in Jin Yong's novels as a selfish, cold and cruel ruler. He was afraid that his power would be eroded, so he used various means to cover up his crimes, such as ordering the massacre of cities, arresting and exiling innocent people, and strengthening the surveillance and control of officials. Emperor Chongzhen was also portrayed as someone who cared nothing about the sufferings of the people and only wanted to eliminate his political opponents, so he often took extreme measures. The Ming Dynasty and Chongzhen in Jin Yong's novels are portrayed as negative elements in history, which is in stark contrast to the positive characters in the novel. The positive characters in the novel were usually portrayed as brave, upright, and responsible characters, while the Ming Dynasty and Chongzhen were portrayed as corrupt, internal and external troubles, selfish, and cruel dynasties, forming a sharp contrast with the characters in the novel. The main reason why Jin Yong belittled the Ming Dynasty and Chongzhen in his novels was to enhance the drama and plot tension of the novel. Although this method might cause some misunderstanding and deviation from historical facts, it was understandable in the creation of novels.