Why are there two different versions of Tang Yin's Song of the Peach Blossom Nunnery? Which one is the original?

Tang Yin's Song of the Peach Blossom Nunnery had two different versions mainly because this poem had many different sources and explanations in history. The different versions might have come from different times and backgrounds of writing. One version of the Song of Peach Blossom Nunnery was written by Tang Bohu, a Tang Dynasty poet, and the other was written by Su Shi, a Song Dynasty litterer. Therefore, the content, style, and expression of these two versions were different. Tang Yin's Song of the Peach Blossom Nunnery had no fixed version at first. The later versions mainly came from different writing times and backgrounds. Therefore, it was impossible to determine which one could only be chosen according to one's own understanding and preferences.

There were two versions of Tang Yin's " Song of the Peach Blossom Nunnery " to identify which one was the original and explain the reason. According to records, there were two versions of Tang Yin's " Song of the Peach Blossom Nunnery." One was a novel in " Records of the Eastern Zhou Dynasty " written by the Ming Dynasty writer Feng Menglong, and the other was a novel in " Dream of the Red Chamber " from the Qing Dynasty. The two versions were different in terms of content, style, and so on, so it was difficult to determine which was the original. There was a big difference in content between the Song of the Peach Blossom Nunnery in the Records of the Eastern Zhou Dynasty and the Song of the Peach Blossom Nunnery in the Dream of the Red Chamber. The Song of the Peach Blossom Nunnery in the Records of the Eastern Zhou Dynasty mainly described the historical stories of the Zhou Dynasty, while the Song of the Peach Blossom Nunnery in the Dream of the Red Chamber described the love story of Jia Baoyu and Lin Daiyu. Records of the Eastern Zhou Dynasty and Dream of the Red Chamber were both representative works of Chinese classical novels. They represented different literary schools and aesthetic tastes. Therefore, it was impossible to simply determine which version was the original version. It required specific analysis.

Tang Yin's original "Song of the Peach Blossom Nunnery" was generally believed to be a poem written by the Ming Dynasty writer Tang Bohu, titled "Song of the Peach Blossom Nunnery." With peach blossoms as the theme, the poem described the poet drinking tea, playing chess and writing in the Peach Blossom Monastery, and expressed his feelings about life. However, there were also some people who believed that "Song of the Peach Blossom Nunnery" was not written by Tang Yin but was compiled by later generations. The main reason for this point of view was that there were many words and grammar that did not conform to the style of Tang Dynasty poetry, as well as the differences with Tang Yin's other works. Therefore, there were different opinions and debates on which was the real version of Tang Yin's Song of the Peach Blossom Nunnery.

Official Sea Sword Washing Record.😋I recommend this wuxia fantasy novel to you. It's called "Records of Washing Swords in the Official Sea." It borrows Tang Yin's Peach Blossom Nunnery Song as the beginning and tells the story of the protagonist's brilliant life in the official sea. I hope you like this fairy's recommendation. Muah ~😗

The Song of the Peach Blossom Nunnery was written by Li Yu, a writer of the Ming Dynasty, not Tang Yin. Li Yu (1618-1680) was a famous writer, dramatist, novelist, and ideologist in the Ming Dynasty. His representative works include Xiang Gui Ji and Lian Xiang Companion. Tang Bohu (1470-1529) was a writer and painter of the Ming Dynasty. His representative works include Song of Peach Blossom Nunnery and Nine Sun Mountain City. Although Tang Bohu and Li Yu both had the surname Li, they were not the same person and their names were different.

The Song of Peach Blossom Nunnery was an ancient poem by Tang Yin, a painter of the Ming Dynasty. The complete poem was as follows: Peach Blossom Monastery under the Peach Blossom Nunnery is the Peach Blossom Fairy. Peach Blossom Fairy Man Peaches And pluck peach blossoms to sell wine money. Waking up from drunkenness, only sitting in front of flowers Drunken, I still come to sleep under the flowers. Half awake, half drunk, day after day Flowers bloom and fall year after year. Others laugh at me for being too crazy I laugh at others for not seeing through me. I can't see the tombs of heroes in the Five Mausoleums no flowers, no wine, hoes for farming. This poem used the Peach Blossom Immortal as the theme to describe a dreamy scene of drunk lying under flowers. The poem conveyed a feeling of transcendence and indifference to fame and fortune through peach blossoms, immortals, peach trees, wine, money and other elements. At the same time, it also showed the author's open-mindedness and optimism, as well as his understanding of life and time.

The Song of Peach Blossom Nunnery was a poem by Tang Yin, a painter of the Ming Dynasty. The whole poem is as follows: Peach Blossom Monastery under the Peach Blossom Nunnery is the Peach Blossom Fairy. Peach Blossom Fairy Man Peaches And pluck peach blossoms for wine money. Waking up from drunkenness, only sitting in front of flowers Drunken, I still come to sleep under the flowers. Half awake, half drunk, day after day Flowers bloom and fall year after year. I hope the flowers will bloom forever the flowers bloom not long, the wine still remains. There's wine in the cup, but it's hard to get drunk it's hard to get drunk with sorrow, hard to get drunk with sorrow. Peach Blossom Monastery under the Peach Blossom Nunnery is the Peach Blossom Fairy. Peach Blossom Fairy Man Peaches And pluck peach blossoms for wine money. Waking up from drunkenness, only sitting in front of flowers Drunken, I still come to sleep under the flowers. Half awake, half drunk, day after day Flowers bloom and fall year after year. I hope the flowers will bloom forever the flowers bloom not long, the wine still remains. There's wine in the cup, but it's hard to get drunk it's hard to get drunk with sorrow, hard to get drunk with sorrow. This poem depicted the life of a peach blossom fairy who lived under a peach blossom nunnery. When he woke up from drinking, he would only sit in front of the flowers. When he drank too much, he would come back to sleep under the flowers. He made a living by planting peach trees and picking peach blossoms to exchange for wine money. At the same time, he enjoyed the beautiful life of endless flowers and wine. The artistic conception of the whole poem was profound and expressed the author's yearning and pursuit for a better life.

Tang Yin's Song of the Peach Blossom Nunnery was a famous martial arts novel. The text was as follows: Peach Blossom Monastery under the Peach Blossom Nunnery is the Peach Blossom Fairy. Peach Blossom Fairy Man Peaches Picking peach blossoms for wine money. Waking up from drunkenness, only sitting in front of flowers Drunken, I still come to sleep under the flowers. Half drunk, half awake, day after day Flowers bloom and fall year after year. I hope the ocean and moon will shed tears I hope we can live together for a long time. The author is Tang Yin, also known as Bo Hu, the owner of Peach Blossom Nunnery, a Suzhou City. This poem was written during the Zhengde period of the Ming Dynasty and was one of Tang Bohu's representative works.

Song of the Peach Blossom Nunnery was an ancient poem written by Tang Bohu, a writer of the Ming Dynasty. It described the scene of him drinking and composing poems in the Peach Blossom Nunnery, as well as his helplessness and emotion towards life. The following is an appreciation of this poem: Song of the Peach Blossom Nunnery portrayed an open-minded and unrestrained image of Tang Bohu. In the poem, he was in the Peach Blossom Monastery and called himself the "Peach Blossom Immortal". He drank and made merry freely. The Peach Blossom Nunnery that he described was a quiet place with a strong cultural atmosphere. Here, he drank and composed poems to express his lofty aspirations and understanding of life, showing an open-minded and free personality. The scene depicted by Tang Bohu in the poem reflected his helplessness and emotion towards life. He used the Peach Blossom Monastery to express the loneliness and loneliness in the depths of his heart. In the Peach Blossom Monastery, he was one with nature, but he could not get rid of the shackles of society and could not be truly free. This contradictory mood reflected the depression and hesitation in the hearts of ancient scholars. Song of the Peach Blossom Nunnery portrayed Tang Bohu, who was full of personality and romanticism, with its open-minded, free and unrestrained poetic style. It represented a kind of aesthetic style and spiritual meaning of ancient Chinese poetry, which provided important enlightenment for later literary creation.

The meaning of Tang Bohu's "Song of the Peach Blossom Nunnery" was: In the Peach Blossom Cove, under the Peach Blossom Nunnery, there is a Peach Blossom Fairy. Peach Blossom Immortal planted peach trees and plucked peach blossoms to exchange for wine money. I sit in front of flowers when I'm sober, and sleep under flowers when I'm drunk. Half awake and half drunk, day after day, flowers fall and bloom year after year. I hope that flowers will bloom for a long time. This poem described Tang Bohu's life under the Peach Blossom Monastery and his pursuit of love. In the poem, the peach blossom fairy planted peach trees and picked peach blossoms to exchange for wine money as a metaphor to express Tang Bohu's obsession and pursuit of love.