It was difficult to tell which one had a more tragic fate, Fugui in Alive or Ye Zang in Disqualification, because the things they experienced and the challenges they faced were different. In " Alive ", Fugui was a farmer. He experienced a series of unfortunate things such as the tragedy of his family, the loss of his land, the death of his loved ones, and finally left this world at the end of his life. He struggled in the journey of life but eventually lost everything. His life could be said to be tragic. And in 'Human Disqualification,' Azo experienced his own personality breakdown and a lonely life. He was confused and desperate about his own existence and finally gave up his life. Even though he once had beautiful dreams and hopes, his life still ended tragically. From the point of view of the two stories, they are both tragic fates, but their tragic experiences and reasons are different.